ptatc

I think most people have been saying that all season in light of the labor impasse coming in 2027

This one i agree with you on.

This guy plays every infield position

Yeah, he obviously wasn't worth much so even a utility type guy was worth it.

Maybe Rojas will be gone?

Dang.

I agree. That's huge if true.

We'll see if he can build the team. That will be the proof.

Personally, I thinks its just time to move on from the while situation. So in this case I probably would have.

Yes, its on hom. Its his job to determine if the return is worth the trade. Just because a bunch of people on a posting board want it done doesn't mean its always the right thing. The jury is still out on Getz. Well know on a couple of years.

Because i dont agree. I understand your point. I just dont agree.

So would you rather be mad at a light return or mad that a trade isnt made. Irrationality is real.

Not colluding but reports are that at least one team valued civale more than Houser. May all the teams are looking at his bad K/bb ratio and other stats and think he isnt as good. During trade time we tend to over value our own players. Would you rather be mad at a light return or mad that the trade wasnt made?

Agreed.

That's the key. He should be worth. Bit what are the offers?

I would sell high. If its was anything worth it. Seems teams think Civale has more value than Houser by reports.

If the offer is just a DSL flyer or the equivalent, yes. Depends on the offer. Why would he trade him for something that's not worth it? He does have intrinsic value for the team. I would trade all of them if they could get something of value. I just dont know what the offers were to make that decision.

Sorry. Didn't realize i wasnt allowed to express my opinion on WHO I wanted to see. We are talking all about retread pitchers here. If they aren't getting anything worth it back I want to see the current pitcher continue to pitch the innings.

True but at least its some quality.

Ewww. I forgot about Perez though. I have no interest in seeing any of the others.

I forgot about Perez. I have no interest in seeing the other 2. If they have to shut down Smith or any of the others. They'll probably need them though.

I think he is valuable enough to take innings from the young pitchers to protect thoer arms if they dont have a offer of anything more than just a flyer. Someone will need to throw the innings.

Agreed, still sucks they aren't dealing him though.

Sorry. Thought I read he was over.

Don't think so. That's just a comment on the general reactions. Can't say its the same.