southsider2k5

You will excuse me after the whole idea that they were perfectly happy with Luis Robert and keeping him because they wanted him crap of 5 seconds ago.

It goes to the He CoUlDn"T hAvE gOtTeN vAlUe trash floating out there about this apparently being the ONLY time they could have traded Robert, and therefore this return now can rush to be justified by the HeGetzUs crew.

We all recognized that Luis Robert had a career year in 2023. We all recognized that it was the first time Luis Robert had been healthy for a full season, outside of his 60 game COVID season, including the minors. What were the odds of Luis Robert being both healthy and productive going forward, when he had never done it before. Understanding that Peak Value Luis Robert was almost certainly after 2023, you also have to recognize that if Luis Robert goes back to injured and/or not productive, his value drops immensely, that even if you didn't get VaLuE for him in 2023, that this ACTUAL return was almost certainly going to be the best you ever got because at the same time you are expecting him to return to his career norms, he was also getting exponentially more expensive. Being a good GM isn't about keeping the masses happy, it's about being smarter than the masses. If Chris Getz kept Luis Robert because he was worry about people like me on a message board, he is in the wrong line of work. Who cares what fans would have thought if it was the smartest move, and on top of it all, he KNEW THIS WAS GOING TO BE A TERRIBLE baseball team going forward that would take half a decade to rebuild. That timeline only emphasizes the point to sell as soon as humanly possible on Robert. So while now we have to pretend to be happy about a halloween prank of a return because ThIs Is WhAt He Is WoRtH nOw, we could have done something years ago, and that can't be ignored.

The fact that you still can't let go of me is so cute. 💓

This is being happy you got scrap value for your wrecked Ferrari which you crashed driving drunk in an ice storm after you could have sold it for six figures previously. Sure it is value for NOW, but realistically, you blew it, and this was the short straw.

This is CRAZY.

This was the predictable part. We were never going to get much for him, which is what made holding on to him for so long in the first place so odd. If Chris Getz really knew this was a historic dumpster fire, the time to deal him was very obviously coming off of 2023 when he was healthy and good for the first time (and still last time) in his career. And every year his value kept dropping like a stone.

I mean he is either successful and we trade him, or he isn't and we eat the cash. If he is too successful, he is going to go FA, and get the big deal he wanted initially from someone else. I guess we can hope that things change internally after the lock out/strike and our ownership situation, but eh.

The highlight of the winter was signing a Japanese star to a 2 year deal for about 15 to 20% of what he was expected to get before the off-season started, and only because the owner had to be begged to outlay $40 million. The Sox had a bit of goodwill for about 15 seconds there, and then back to the dumpster.

No this is the generic, non-copyrighted version you don't have to pay royalties for.

"Blown away" by the chance to grab another post hype utility player. Can't wait for his hot two weeks to declare this another win.

And they didn't have to trade him. Hahahahaha

Honestly it will be a small miracle if the second guy ever makes a 40 man roster

I smell the 2026 Marketing campaign.

The whole league knew Getz had to trade Robert, and apparently after the big splash, knew the Sox were also broke. Worst Poker Player, Ever.

Would have much rather had the Reds post hype and MASH pile than the bag of burning dog poo.

Post hype utility low pop hitters at that.

This year too from the reporting.

"Nothing" seems like a pretty accurate description of the return.

It's wild what free agents are going for, and we still sucked hind tit with Robert, refusing to pick up cash to the end to get an actual return.

This is such a D list operation.

https://www.amazinavenue.com/2025/7/16/24468646/2025-mets-draft-profile-truman-pauley-rhp Apparently Pauley is a data darling whose never really been good.

ThEy DoNt HaVe To TrAdE hIm

If we picked up cash for this return, burn the franchise down. If we didn't pay cash, and this is why we got a garbage return, burn the franchise down.

it's wild the difference in the game comes down to a bunch of dudes deciding not to block on a punt.