Dick Allen

The funny thing is Collins is terrible defensively but Seby is stout, yet in half as many games Seby has twice as many PB. Collins has a much better CS percentage, Collins does have 4 errors to 1. The WP with each catching is a similar number if you just count pace. If Collins is pure garbage, Seby is as well. One of the things I always hated about LaRussa and I mentioned this before the season is he always falls in love with the weakest players on the roster. It's almost like he is doing this to try to prove he is smarter than everyone.

There is nothing in the rulebook that says a tie goes to the runner, but technically it should. If you have the frame where the ball is deemed caught, a tie would me the foot is on first, and that would be safe. The problem is they are guessing a lot of times when the ball is actually caught. The 1/1000 of a second makes a huge difference.

The first one you can see not challenging until you see the replay with the foot on first base and the ball a couple of feet from the glove.

If they are so down on Collins, they think Seby is ahead of him, not trading for a back up catcher at the deadine is curious. They don't cost much.

I am still trying to figure out why Seby is considered so great defensively. Another PB yesterday, so 6 in 20 starts. Hardly,ever throws anyone out 15 SB 1 CS, granted a lot of that is on the pitchers, but I think he has made some awful throws.

The only excuse was the video wasn't working, and even then, turn on a TV and watch your broadcast. I was at the game so I didn't see it, but I would have been pissed. Hernandez was also baffled by the lack of challenge. I just chalked it up to too close, it wouldn't have been changed. Either that, or he was watching porn.

The first one, which is the second picture,if it was closer, you could see not challenging since it was the first inning, but that obvious. The other was in the 7th inning, no need to save your challenges not to use them at that point. Very odd.

Kelenic is going to be great, but Harold seems to think he's a combo Mickey Mantle/ Willie Mays only better, and that Mike Trout is a poor man's version of him. OTOH, he also pegs Nick Madrigal as perhaps the worst player to ever play baseball.

So you think anyone with the White Sox questioning him about not challenging is more than likely a no nothing? Looking at replays isn't very sophisticated.

He clearly failed at his job yesterday. If he does a ton, great. Leave replays to someone who can handle the job. Why would the 29 other major league teams be able to challenge the play, but you are making excuses for this guy? Pretend his last name is Madrigal.

The second one isn't even close. But that isn't on the manager. That is on the replay room.

And in 2004 the Red Sox came back from 0-3 to defeat the Yankees. So in 2005 when they fell behind 0-2 vs the White Sox, they were perfectly positioned. The Indians came up short in 2005 and will be shortin 2021. They gave up.

I don't necessarily think his Dh ing is a sign he is far away. Catching is brutal. They may be saving him until the bat is ready.

Sox really need at least 3 out of 4 vs Oakland, probably need to sweep to be in a good position to win the division. Cleveland might get to .500 some day.

Usually it takes more than 30 seconds for posts not to age well. Congrats!

You know your baseball.

Pure garbage double by pure garbage player Collins.

You need to treat every game as must win because when you only have a 10 game lead, it is. If that means pitching your top guys 100+ games a year so be it.Besides if Hendriks comes in and gives up a homer we can b**** about it, him and his contract all night.

Who are you going to use?

What a joke. If they were in a real division they might set a record for losses in a season. Total fail.

Foster won't be on the roster.

What's with Vaughn not crushing a guy throwing100 mph sinkers? This is why you never draft 1B #3 overall.

If you don't hit .600 or if you pitch and give up a run,, or if you ever make an error, you suck.

I don't like Tony, but I agree. It is amazing how many are in their glory when the Sox are losing.

Except for 1 game in his career, Zabala is a .140 hitter and the guy behind Mr is bitching Collins hit for him.