3 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:

Just a thought exercise, but if you could pull these two trades off would you:

Trade #1:

• CWS get: RHP Mason Miller

• SDP get: SS Billy Carlson, RHP Tanner McDougal, IF William Bergolla, OF George Wolkow

Trade #2:

• CWS get: LHP Reid Detmers

• LAA get: LHP Hagen Smith, C Edgar Quero, 2B Javier Mogollon

YesYes to trade 2. Can't see even a new GM taking Quero back as the secondary piece, though.

No to trade 1.

7 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:

Just a thought exercise, but if you could pull these two trades off would you:

Trade #1:

• CWS get: RHP Mason Miller

• SDP get: SS Billy Carlson, RHP Tanner McDougal, IF William Bergolla, OF George Wolkow

Trade #2:

• CWS get: LHP Reid Detmers

• LAA get: LHP Hagen Smith, C Edgar Quero, 2B Javier Mogollon

No, I wouldn't trade my top prospects at their lowest possible value especially when we literally just drafted them 1 and 2 years ago.

3 minutes ago, joejoesox said:

No, I wouldn't trade my top prospects at their lowest possible value especially when we literally just drafted them 1 and 2 years ago.

Who would you trade for a SP? Mason Miller is a luxury that we probably can’t afford without giving up Bonemer. But we have to add a SP…you prefer going the rental route?

6 minutes ago, joejoesox said:

No, I wouldn't trade my top prospects at their lowest possible value especially when we literally just drafted them 1 and 2 years ago.

I'm curious what the Giants would give up in return for your first package. I want Webb and Ray.

20 minutes ago, joejoesox said:

No, I wouldn't trade my top prospects at their lowest possible value especially when we literally just drafted them 1 and 2 years ago.

but what if you got a pitcher with a career 5 ERA in return?

1 hour ago, Look at Ray Ray Run said:

How does Wikelman have "real trade value?" An ERA over 5 with a 1.333 whip in the minors.

Guy provides thoughtful 40 man roster crunch analysis and comes up with a solid list of trade candidates and your response is to nitpick one piece of it? Lol, youre such a know it all

34 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:

Just a thought exercise, but if you could pull these two trades off would you:

Trade #1:

• CWS get: RHP Mason Miller

• SDP get: SS Billy Carlson, RHP Tanner McDougal, IF William Bergolla, OF George Wolkow

Trade #2:

• CWS get: LHP Reid Detmers

• LAA get: LHP Hagen Smith, C Edgar Quero, 2B Javier Mogollon

Wouldn’t do number 1, think I’d be ok with number 2

37 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:

Just a thought exercise, but if you could pull these two trades off would you:

Trade #1:

• CWS get: RHP Mason Miller

• SDP get: SS Billy Carlson, RHP Tanner McDougal, IF William Bergolla, OF George Wolkow

Trade #2:

• CWS get: LHP Reid Detmers

• LAA get: LHP Hagen Smith, C Edgar Quero, 2B Javier Mogollon

Would do #2 if I had to choose.

1 hour ago, Chicago White Sox said:

Because he was awesome before his injury (2.33 ERA | 12.86 K/9 | 3.21 BB/9 | 1.00 WHIP), has big time stuff, and has a 73rd percentile xwOBA in AAA despite playing half his games at Truist Field. Him having a couple of bad appearances while coming back from injury doesn’t change my evaluation of him.

There are tons of minor league relievers who have good stuff and poor command that holds them back.

16 minutes ago, Bonemer, I Hardly Know Her said:

Guy provides thoughtful 40 man roster crunch analysis and comes up with a solid list of trade candidates and your response is to nitpick one piece of it? Lol, youre such a know it all

It was a question about the list he provided. That's how people communicate on forums, they see something and ask for clarification.

Maybe you should go create another user name instead of policing responses that ask simple questions.

with the Angels wanting a young catcher, I’m all about sending Quero back to them