4 minutes ago, WestEddy said:

This seems like a good idea. Honestly, I would probably dump Hays because you know he’s just going to get injured again.

1 hour ago, Chicago White Sox said:

Five days or less until Detmers is a White Sox. Just a prediction, but I am very confident it happens. Soxtalk won’t be a fun place afterwards if it does…lol.

anyone telegraphed this long is unlikely to happen, imo.

I think Hagan Smith is the starting point for Detmers, I wouldn't give up Bonemer or Carlson for him.

If you gave up say Hagan, Lodise, and Gabe Davis (I personally think that is a little light) for Detmers, and Mason Adams, Landon Hodge, and Mongollon for Singer and Stevenson, that would be great with me. Add in Hays for a mid inning reliever.

14 minutes ago, Rusty_Kuntz said:

I think Hagan Smith is the starting point for Detmers, I wouldn't give up Bonemer or Carlson for him.

If you gave up say Hagan, Lodise, and Gabe Davis (I personally think that is a little light) for Detmers, and Mason Adams, Landon Hodge, and Mongollon for Singer and Stevenson, that would be great with me. Add in Hays for a mid inning reliever.

I wouldn't even blink at this.

At this point I have extreme doubts that Smith is a starter.

30 minutes ago, WestEddy said:

This guy isn’t legit

Start by trading Reinsdorf for an average street vendor

17 minutes ago, fathom said:

This guy isn’t legit

I know. It's out there, tho. Here's another:

45 minutes ago, WestEddy said:

It makes a lot of sense if either of them have enough value to get there. It could even be a dump for a nothing MiLB player to get the roster spot open.

11 minutes ago, Thesieve300 said:

Start by trading Reinsdorf for an average street vendor

Now we are talking overpay.

I don’t trust this Travis Hudson guy… simply because of his profile picture.

Grichuk being healthy and productive this year (and making league minimum) would make him much more attractive to teams. But also, I would probably want to keep him over Hays.

2 hours ago, Chicago White Sox said:

Five days or less until Detmers is a White Sox. Just a prediction, but I am very confident it happens. Soxtalk won’t be a fun place afterwards if it does…lol.

I'd be very surprised. Asking price sounds astronomical.

1 hour ago, WestEddy said:

Fake account

33 minutes ago, WestEddy said:

I know. It's out there, tho. Here's another:

Fake account.

3 minutes ago, Bob Sacamano said:

It could be if he goes for less than people think he’ll go for

My official prediction is Carlson, Quero, & Adams and I think most people will hate that.

5 minutes ago, Chicago White Sox said:

My official prediction is Carlson, Quero, & Adams and I think most people will hate that.

If this was the price for Detmers, I think he'd be here already.

7 minutes ago, Y2Jimmy0 said:

If this was the price for Detmers, I think he'd be here already.

Well that is awful decision making by the White Sox if they are willing to give up a high upside prospect like Carlson for a pitcher like Detmers. It is paying a premium for cost control vs. eliteness and that is not a trade off this organization should ever make. If you want to move Carlson in a package for Miller - I don't love it, but I get behind the fact you are getting an elite cost controlled player, but at a less premium position. That is an acceptable trade off.

14 hours ago, Chicago White Sox said:

I noticed this is the minor league thread. Very weird they used him in this capacity when we are desperate for SP and have already punted on Hagen & McDougal being used in those roles.

It’s really hard for me to see Hagen succeed in the bullpen when his biggest problem is putting it over the plate.

35 minutes ago, hi8is said:

I don’t trust this Travis Hudson guy… simply because of his profile picture.

Good eye. It's a stock photo

https://tineye.com/search/6ad0d4a58793380a3b61991570f2bd0847a25962?sort=score&order=desc&page=1

We have a new Foodies invasion. Instead of food it’s just stock photo normie guys

5 minutes ago, Chisoxfn said:

Well that is awful decision making by the White Sox if they are willing to give up a high upside prospect like Carlson for a pitcher like Detmers. It is paying a premium for cost control vs. eliteness and that is not a trade off this organization should ever make. If you want to move Carlson in a package for Miller - I don't love it, but I get behind the fact you are getting an elite cost controlled player, but at a less premium position. That is an acceptable trade off.

Detmers is pretty damn good.

10 minutes ago, Y2Jimmy0 said:

If this was the price for Detmers, I think he'd be here already.

I would bet money that package is better than what he goes for.