First off there's a lot more sources than MLB.com that put him in the middle of the rotation types. 2.We could do this all day because I'll tell you some sources that did just that. My apologies to the old thinkers that think AI is evil but any time you use Google search to research things you get multiple sources very quickly so if you rather ask who didn't like Dustin May you're going to come up with MLB.com thing you cited. 3. Fans say they want to improve our analytics and pitching and hitting labs but then when they do that and make a signing that may depend a little more of the pitching lab to work on a few things it's a bad signing. The Brewers , Rays, & Guardians seem to do very well with pitchers and the Brewers gave up 2 decent prospects for him and the Sox hired Matt Roffe from the Brewers. He's been known to take calculated risks on upside. I think that perfectly describes May given he's still in the prime of his career being a young 29 yr. old and basically having him from ages 29, 30 and 31 and his velocity went up on a number of pitches and he has a 6 pitch mix so they will likely work on how he approaches LHH. Some like his cutter, they might work on his changeup or suggest adding a slider or get more movement on his curve or sweeper. He's tall so he gets good extension. Cutter is what ended up helping Crochet and that was worked in after he struggled early in his breakout year even though he worked on it in Spring training but didn't feel comfortable with it. Working on Fedde's sweeper worked with him. But he wasn't going to start 30 games. Command is harder to get right but they did some good work with Hagen and Hicks too. 4. The Sox pitching Lab will have a lot more time to work with May and tweak some things. Getting a player in season and trying to get more on the fly is a difficult proposition even if you are the Brewers. 5.I keep asking for discussion on it so accusing me (not necessarily you but others who you agree with) of trying to mute discussions is just wrong and deceitful. I ask who do you want that would make you happy and very few will answer it because no one is willing to do the research on 50+ SP and just outright afraid to actually name 5 guys after Skubal who you would prefer to get now that we have May ? Actual discussion where you make multiple points is like taboo because OMG I have to read all that ? Most expect others to make their points for them. But I'll stand by my statement that 90% of the guys in the middle tier would have been deemed undesirable by the casual and even the not so casual twitter fan base who just go with the loudest and noisiest group of dissenters. It is a weak class of SP. So who liked May besides the Brewers at the TDL and the 9-10 teams that were looking to sign him? So first lets get the number of starting pitchers available in FA and then try to see who liked May in the upper half rather then your MLB.com bottom tier stuff for all FA. Basically there are or were 57 FA SP The Athletic , Keith Law ranked May #8 or in the top 14% of all Starting pitchers. NY Times. Fangraphs, Ben Clemens had him at #10 or top 17.5 %. He had 2.8 fWar which ranked him 6th highest among all Free agent starters. Skubal,Rogers, Gray,Gausman & Nick Martinez ahead of him. Fangraphs Crowd sourcing median predicting had him at 3yrs/$48M CBS Sports, Mike Axisa had him 11th or Top 19.3%. CBS Sports splits data May held opponents to a 0.89ERA with thebases empty(81.1 IP) but allowed a 17.94 ERA with runners in scoring position (.350 BAA). Because RISP performance tends to regress towards the mean year-over-year, analysts expect his ERA to drop closer to the 3.80-4.15 range in 2027 and that's without factoring in any improvement against LHH MLB.com in a different ranking by fWar over the last 2 seasons had him 17th or top 29.8% ESPN, Kiley McDaniel had him #22 or top 38.6 % May consistently landed in the 8-22 range and he's viewed as a Tier 3 mid rotation upside arm in a very thin pitching market. In a vaccuum he's not ideal but if paired with a Rogers, Gray, King, Nick Martinez, Peralta, Taira or anyone else you consider worthy then its ok to try to find the upside in one of the younger FA SP. That's really the whole crux of the matter. We just have to wait and hopefully get our answer before Dec. 1st. If not, it's going to be an angst filled off season for most of you. I suggest to anyone you needs to know more about May to read the Ben Clemens article in Fangraphs that he posted yesterday. Just search for May and look for Clemens blog post. He points out the problems and the potential and the metrics that have been discussed by only a few.