Favorite has always been a bit different to me. It doesn't have much to do with how good they are, but how much they love the game and entertain fans. If Yolmer were still on the team, he would be my #1, and was when he was on the roster.
My favorite today is Tim Anderson He is a raw and authentic guy, who is out there to have fun and escape the world.
Also a huge fan of Jose Abreu. The guy realizes how lucky he is in life, and is doing everything he can to spread that love and luck to other players.
Eloys just pure joy around the game is addictive.
I know they are also some of the best players on the team, but they would be favorites of mine, no matter what their numbers looked like.