What say you?

 

Lots of good answers in this one ^

5/4/3/2/1:

1. Seaver

2. Buehrle

3. Peavy

4. Fernandez

5. Stone

15 Philip Humbers. Bring it on.

11 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:

What say you?

 

Absolutely ASININE that Sale is not $5 let along not on this list.

I'm going the White Sox way.  All the $2 dollar guys and pocket the 5 I got left.  

2 minutes ago, Squirmin' for Yermin said:

Absolutely ASININE that Sale is not $5 let along not on this list.

There are no active pitchers on this list.

Ok, but actually,

Ed Walsh  $5

Tom Seaver  $5

Wilbur Wood  $3

Freddy Garcia  $2

 

With those guys, I only need 4.  And I'll still get 1k innings.  

 

Edited January 18, 20233 yr by turnin' two

4 Mark 

3 José 

2 Freddy, Alex, Wilson, keep the change

28 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:

There are no active pitchers on this list.

Then Chris Sale should be on there?

1 minute ago, Quin said:

Then Chris Sale should be on there?

Early Wynn

Billy Pierce

Mark Buerhle

Floyd Banister

Gavin Floyd

Buehrle

Black Jack

Contreras

Alex Fernandez

Wilson Alvarez

If Sale we’re on the list it would definitely change the calculus, but alas. 

1. Faber

2. Lyons

3. Walsh

These guys are used to a 3 man rotation so that's easy enough.

1 hour ago, turnin' two said:

I'm going the White Sox way.  All the $2 dollar guys and pocket the 5 I got left.  

Jerry would be so proud.

 

Billy Pierce $4
Buehrle $4

Jake Peavy $3

Sweaty Freddy $2

Steve Stone $1 

$1 donate to charity 

"Hey what is the deal with making someone spend $15?  Is this the MLBPA trying to force a minimum salary floor??  

  "You cannot spend $15 when you only have a quarter, sorry."

3 hours ago, southsider2k5 said:

What say you?

 

WHERE IS Odrisamer Despaigne?

6 minutes ago, Joshua Strong said:

WHERE IS Odrisamer Despaigne?

I will always remember fondly that guy....the pitcher who hated to warm up....."I'm ready, let's go."

Also, with how much you had to spend on the starting rotation, Despaigne will have to be in the bullpen, along with Jose Paniagua.

Edited January 18, 20233 yr by wegner

Seaver, Fernandez, Black Jack, Pierce, Alvarez

Well $3 for a guy with multiple 10+ WAR seasons seems like the mother of all no brainers

I'll take the 4$ option

12 hours ago, southsider2k5 said:

What say you?

 

I'm assuming guys can pitch 8-9 innings so I will list NOBODY from the current era. My rotation: Seaver (in his prime; he still was pretty damn good with the Sox); Buehrle, McDowell in his prime and Gary Peters. Honorable mention: Hoyt of that one special season and Wood (the guy once started both ends of a DH). Early Wynn and Pierce and Lyons and those old guys can be honorary pitching coaches. I realize they might be the best of the bunch for all I know.

Edited January 19, 20233 yr by greg775

I'll take 5 Alex Fernandez's and spend the leftover $5 on a right fielder.

42 minutes ago, Sarava said:

I'll take 5 Alex Fernandez's and spend the leftover $5 on a right fielder.

Lol.

Edited January 19, 20233 yr by Jack Parkman

Buerhle, McDowell, Wood, Alvarez, Stone and Floyd for spot starts