3 hours ago3 hr 5 minutes ago, CBJ03 said:It wouldn’t be Soxtalk if everyone didn’t b**** about every decision made. More people would be happy here if he absolutely imploded then if he was decent to good so they could tell you about how awful the signing was 2-3 years after he no longer pitches here.This has all the semblance though of the Castillo deal where it was disliked by almost everyone. Again, as a back of the rotation guy, it’s expensive but ok. Still think we’re going to see something very surprising in terms of a big trade (one of the Montgomery boys)
3 hours ago3 hr 2 minutes ago, Autumn Dreamin said:You can't just look at ERA, but nothing about May's last 2 years says he was overly unlucky. People hit the ball hard off him. He doesn't get a ton of grounders. The stuff is good, but if he hangs a sweeper every start and it gets hit for a homer, is that unlucky? He pitched well for the Cardinals last year, but Busch Stadium is one of the best parks for suppressing homers. He then went to a more neutral park in Milwaukee and gave up 1.72 HR/9 in 10 starts. The stuff is definitely intriguing, but we definitely need the coaching staff to get him to be more consistent. We thought we could fix a guy Seattle couldn't figure out last year. Now we're thinking we know more than the team that just won the World Series.
3 hours ago3 hr 3 minutes ago, fathom said:This has all the semblance though of the Castillo deal where it was disliked by almost everyone. Again, as a back of the rotation guy, it’s expensive but ok. Still think we’re going to see something very surprising in terms of a big trade (one of the Montgomery boys)I think we end up with one of the Japanese pitchers
3 hours ago3 hr 7 minutes ago, chw42 said:FWIW, it seems like Brewers fans hate this guy from what I'm reading on Reddit. Their biggest complaint is that he was inconsistent. Looks like he had 6 starts last year where he blew up, but there were also 11 starts where his game score was over 60. Overall, 18 starts above average, 13 below.I think the Brewers Fans probably have a higher expectations for starting pitchers than most clubs. They have enjoyed significant amount of success. The truth is unless you are spending 35+/ year on a starter their is going to be some gamble involved. Would I rather take the salaries of Castillo+May and get one of those guys. Yeah, probably. However, There is some logic here. May will be now two years removed from TJ. He is still in his prime through out the contract and has some good velo/spin rate. This is a gamble. But this is the White Sox. We are bargain shopping at TJ Max not going to Louis Store.
3 hours ago3 hr 13 minutes ago, chw42 said:FWIW, it seems like Brewers fans hate this guy from what I'm reading on Reddit. Their biggest complaint is that he was inconsistent. Looks like he had 6 starts last year where he blew up, but there were also 11 starts where his game score was over 60. Overall, 18 starts above average, 13 below.Why did I just have Javier Vazquez chills? The king of underpitching his stuff.
3 hours ago3 hr Does this take us out of the running for on of the Japanese guys? I think I would prefer one of those guys if so.
3 hours ago3 hr 35 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:Brutal. Overpaying for injury-prone mediocrity. Typical White Sox. I’d rather bring back Fedde than overpay May.This shouldn't shut the door on Fedde if they want him back
3 hours ago3 hr 1 minute ago, wegner said:This shouldn't shut the door on Fedde if they want him backFedde is great as a swing type of guy, if you are counting on him as more, that's no good.
3 hours ago3 hr 47 minutes ago, Capn12 said:So the rotation is Burke, Martin, Shultz, May, Castillo, Taylor in some combination?We are likely adding another starter. Probably one of the Japanese players or King/Peralta.
2 hours ago2 hr 11 minutes ago, CBJ03 said:More people would be happy here if he absolutely imploded then if he was decent to good so they could tell you about how awful the signing was 2-3 years after he no longer pitches here.People want good things for the Sox. That’s where the criticism comes from.Why are you pretending to not understand basic fandom?
2 hours ago2 hr 5 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:Why did I just have Javier Vazquez chills? The king of underpitching his stuff.It does seem a bit like that. But I get that anytime I see a guy with good stuff whose results don't match his good but not elite peripherals.
2 hours ago2 hr 4 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:Why did I just have Javier Vazquez chills? The king of underpitching his stuff.Wonder if today's game Vazquez would top out at 5 inni gs per start. This guy is an arm betting on upside. I think they look at a high leverage 2 to 3 inning guy few times a week.
2 hours ago2 hr Sox really cornering the market on #4/5 starters.Dustin May Stinks.Wouldn't call him an analytics darling. Dude had one year with a decent FIP but he still ran a 4.43 xERA last year. They needed a top of the rotation starter and instead they got Dustin May. Doesn't K guys, doesn't generate ground balls. Nice profile. Edited 2 hours ago2 hr by Look at Ray Ray Run
2 hours ago2 hr Still need at least 1 more starter but glad they signed someone. Did they target him specifically or was he the guy willing to accept an offer before 12/1?
2 hours ago2 hr 16 minutes ago, Whisox05 said:There couldn't two more incomparable players unless you compared it to signing a fielder.
2 hours ago2 hr 21 minutes ago, Baron said:Oh so this is it? How much do you want to bet?That goes for anyone. You think this will be the biggest move this offseason?Why do you have so much confidence in Jerry letting Getz spend money? @southsider2k5 and @T R U are right in that these are the exact type of signings we typically see. A few Tier C guys are acquired rather than one or two Tier A and Tier B guys. The Sox always take quantity over quality. Edited 2 hours ago2 hr by WhiteSox2023
2 hours ago2 hr 7 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:Fedde is great as a swing type of guy, if you are counting on him as more, that's no good.Totally agree with you...just saying he shouldn't be expensive if they want to bring him back. Fedde closing out the Astros for the wild card win was probably my favorite post season moment.
2 hours ago2 hr 6 minutes ago, Look at Ray Ray Run said:Sox really cornering the market on #4/5 starters.Dustin May Stinks.Wouldn't call him an analytics darling. Dude had one year with a decent FIP but he still ran a 4.43 xERA last year. They needed a top of the rotation starter and instead they got Dustin May. Doesn't K guys, doesn't generate ground balls. Nice profile.Good to see you back. 😘
2 hours ago2 hr 1 minute ago, wegner said:Totally agree with you...just saying he shouldn't be expensive if they want to bring him back. Fedde closing out the Astros for the wild card win was probably my favorite post season moment.If you get him in that $3 to 5 million range for a year of back end fill in, slash, bulk innings out of the pen guy, I am 100% on board.
2 hours ago2 hr 3 minutes ago, Harry Chappas said:There couldn't two more incomparable players unless you compared it to signing a fielder.Unless the top guys turned him down for less money so we flipped to May, I don't get it. Dallas always over pitched his stuff with movement tricks and consistency until his trick got shut down, and then he just sucked. May is all stuff with no consistency.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.