Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Soxtalk.com

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

White Sox sign Dustin May to 3Y/50M+ deal

Featured Replies

7 minutes ago, Look at Ray Ray Run said:

Sox really cornering the market on #4/5 starters.

Dustin May Stinks.

Wouldn't call him an analytics darling. Dude had one year with a decent FIP but he still ran a 4.43 xERA last year. They needed a top of the rotation starter and instead they got Dustin May. Doesn't K guys, doesn't generate ground balls. Nice profile.

Yeah but is he better than Anthony Kay, Pal?

Good to see you back, Ray.

  • Replies 94
  • Views 1.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Dustin Meh

  • If Castillo wasn't here I'd like this more. But we'll see. I liked May alot when he was a Dodger. But that was years ago.

  • southsider2k5
    southsider2k5

    It's the eternal Sox debate. They would rather have multiples from Bucket C than one from Bucket A. In this way Getz is a complete copy of Hahn, who was a complete copy of Kenny, which probably mean

Posted Images

19 minutes ago, fathom said:

This has all the semblance though of the Castillo deal where it was disliked by almost everyone. Again, as a back of the rotation guy, it’s expensive but ok. Still think we’re going to see something very surprising in terms of a big trade (one of the Montgomery boys)

Agreed. Not that I think it’s the right strategy, but I think Getz is more likely to trade for a starter than pay the big bucks and years for a high-end free agent starter.

Edited by WhiteSox2023

4 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:

Why do you have so much confidence in Jerry letting Getz spend money? @southsider2k5 and @T R U are right in that these are the exact type of signings we typically see. A few Tier C guys are acquired rather than one or two Tier A and Tier B guys. The Sox always take quantity over quality.

I am absolutely willing to reserve judgement until the market is complete, but this alone isn't it for sure. I am operating under the idea that the Sox may actually be willing to wait out the new CBA to take advantage of over cap teams who need to dump too.

8 minutes ago, Snopek said:

People want good things for the Sox. That’s where the criticism comes from.

Why are you pretending to not understand basic fandom?

I understand it plenty. Everything is an instant reaction of awful all the time. Free agency is always hit or miss and everyone wants to fire every move into the sun as soon as it happens. If they had signed Skubal and it cost $55 million a year people would complain about the price and how it eats up their payroll. Also, players have a say where they go in free agency. Just because you have money to spend doesnt mean guys are interested in playing for you and it could be for a variety of reasons that arent even negative.

Edited by CBJ03

Throw King a high AAV 4 year deal with opt outs and let's go.

2 minutes ago, CBJ03 said:

I understand it plenty. Everything is an instant reaction of awful all the time. Free agency is always hit or miss and everyone wants to fire every move into the sun as soon as it happens. If they had signed Skubal and it cost $55 million a year people would complain about the price and how it eats up their payroll.

People would be too busy still waking up from their fainting spells from shock and disbelief.

This is the most whelming signing possible.

2 minutes ago, wegner said:

Yeah but is he better than Anthony Kay, Pal?

Good to see you back, Ray.

Just a hit and run!

I do think he's better than Anthony Kay.

Everyone out there saying May isn't that bad is someone that has been stanning for him since he was a big prospect. There's a lot not to like about May.

  1. He doesn't go deep into games.

  2. He's never thrown more than 145 innings in a season and that was LAST year

  3. He's been hurt multiple times

  4. His stuff is overrated - he has the 4th highest hard hit rate in MLB among starters with 140+ IP (Behind Sugano and Leahy who no one is giving 50 million too).

  5. He has one of the highest squared up rates in baseball

  6. Played for Dodgers, Brewers and Cardinals... and those orgs couldn't maximize him.

Dustin has never been fooling anyone. His stuff has always been lesser than his outcomes, and he's frequently injured.

Edited by Look at Ray Ray Run

2 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:

People would be too busy still waking up from their fainting spells from shock and disbelief.

I'm willing to do my part and pay an extra $1 for a Cuban Comet to offset that $55 mill for Skubal......ok maybe 50 cents, can't go too crazy now.

21 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:

Why did I just have Javier Vazquez chills? The king of underpitching his stuff.

His 2007 was fantastic and he was ok in 08.

He seems like another one of those guys whose stuff looks crazy but the results never really match it. Hopefully the Sox Pitching Lab has a good plan for him this season

2 minutes ago, Colome's Hat said:

His 2007 was fantastic and he was ok in 08.

….for 5ish innings

4 minutes ago, CBJ03 said:

I understand it plenty. Everything is an instant reaction of awful all the time. Free agency is always hit or miss and everyone wants to fire every move into the sun as soon as it happens. If they had signed Skubal and it cost $55 million a year people would complain about the price and how it eats up their payroll. Also, players have a say where they go in free agency. Just because you have money to spend doesnt mean guys are interested in playing for you and it could be for a variety of reasons that arent even negative.

Sure, that’s fine, and I mostly agree. But saying people would prefer a player, and by extension the Sox, to fail so they can be correct in front of internet strangers feels pretty disingenuous is all.

17 minutes ago, CBJ03 said:

I understand it plenty. Everything is an instant reaction of awful all the time. Free agency is always hit or miss and everyone wants to fire every move into the sun as soon as it happens. If they had signed Skubal and it cost $55 million a year people would complain about the price and how it eats up their payroll. Also, players have a say where they go in free agency. Just because you have money to spend doesnt mean guys are interested in playing for you and it could be for a variety of reasons that arent even negative.

Yeah, no. I would absolutely LOVE the Sox making a move like this that only cost money if they were actually going to be a team that wasn't scared of a contract.

12 minutes ago, Look at Ray Ray Run said:

Just a hit and run!

I do think he's better than Anthony Kay.

Everyone out there saying May isn't that bad is someone that has been stanning for him since he was a big prospect. There's a lot not to like about May.

  1. He doesn't go deep into games.

  2. He's never thrown more than 145 innings in a season and that was LAST year

  3. He's been hurt multiple times

  4. His stuff is overrated - he has the 4th highest hard hit rate in MLB among starters with 140+ IP (Behind Sugano and Leahy who no one is giving 50 million too).

  5. He has one of the highest squared up rates in baseball

  6. Played for Dodgers, Brewers and Cardinals... and those orgs couldn't maximize him.

Dustin has never been fooling anyone. His stuff has always been lesser than his outcomes, and he's frequently injured.

I hear ya.....but......

I'm gonna try to be positive and remember you posted that you do think he's better than Anthony Kay.

15 minutes ago, Look at Ray Ray Run said:

Just a hit and run!

I do think he's better than Anthony Kay.

Everyone out there saying May isn't that bad is someone that has been stanning for him since he was a big prospect. There's a lot not to like about May.

  1. He doesn't go deep into games.

  2. He's never thrown more than 145 innings in a season and that was LAST year

  3. He's been hurt multiple times

  4. His stuff is overrated - he has the 4th highest hard hit rate in MLB among starters with 140+ IP (Behind Sugano and Leahy who no one is giving 50 million too).

  5. He has one of the highest squared up rates in baseball

  6. Played for Dodgers, Brewers and Cardinals... and those orgs couldn't maximize him.

Dustin has never been fooling anyone. His stuff has always been lesser than his outcomes, and he's frequently injured.

Yeah, this is what scares me. Plus if he fails, the won't dump him and admit defeat.

12 minutes ago, Snopek said:

Sure, that’s fine, and I mostly agree. But saying people would prefer a player, and by extension the Sox, to fail so they can be correct in front of internet strangers feels pretty disingenuous is all.

Actual fans would just rather the Sox act like a big market team and take advantage of ALL of the methods of building a team possible. They wouldn't rather be right by predicting what they do, they just usually are, because the Sox leave so much on the shelf.

If the White Sox sign Skubal or Freddy (even King!), I would certainly be excited and wouldn't care what the cost is or offering any criticism.

If the Sox were going to go this route, I would have much preferred David Peterson if we were going "metric darlings" who don't get the same results as projected. Peterson will probably cost about 20% what May costs, and I think their expected outcomes over the next three years are pretty close.

I would have preferred to go Peterson/Mahle if we were going to be shopping in this tier of quality. Prices are lower and expected outcomes are pretty in line.

Chicago Sun-Times
No image preview

White Sox add to starting rotation by signing free-agent...

A source confirmed to the Sun-Times that the Sox have agreed to a three-year, $52.5 million pact with the 29-year-old; their largest free-agent outlay since Andrew Benintendi in 2023.
No image preview

White Sox signing Dustin May to three-year deal - Sox Mac...

The White Sox made no secret about their desire for starting pitching, and so it makes sense that their first move of the offseason addresses that need. Dustin May is in the fold on a three-year, $52.

I am completely at a loss with this move. Like no idea why this would be their choice.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.