7 hours ago7 hr The FIP difference does matter, but it's wild that everyone wanted to give Davis Martin away for free with his 5.4 xERA in the second half, while people were also excited about adding Dustin May with his 5.45 xERA in the second half.Just shows that fans get too high and too low on players depending on recency bias. Either way, I like May more than I like Davis and I think May will be better over the next three years, but Dustin May was atrocious in the second half last year just like Davis, and we gave May 52 million for his services. Weird to be excited about one guy joining the club while also being excited about giving the other guy away for free.
7 hours ago7 hr 3 minutes ago, Look at Ray Ray Run said:The FIP difference does matter, but it's wild that everyone wanted to give Davis Martin away for free with his 5.4 xERA in the second half, while people were also excited about adding Dustin May with his 5.45 xERA in the second half.Just shows that fans get too high and too low on players depending on recency bias.Either way, I like May more than I like Davis and I think May will be better over the next three years, but Dustin May was atrocious in the second half last year just like Davis, and we gave May 52 million for his services.Weird to be excited about one guy joining the club while also being excited about giving the other guy away for free.Losing a bad 25 million dollar contract is free?
7 hours ago7 hr https://www.thebaseballcube.com/content/player/203965/Luis Robert Syndrome with MayUnfilfilled/untapped potential potential potential still at this point, at 29?Peaked at 8th/21st ranked prospect in mlb over two milb seasonsInjury prone.Why not just give Michael Kopech another shot?
7 hours ago7 hr 3 minutes ago, PaleAleSox said:Losing a bad 25 million dollar contract is free?No, it cost Boston Smith and Davis Martin. Far from free.
7 hours ago7 hr Lots of interesting takes and reactions here about MAY and then the trade of CASTILLO and MARTIN.To me, this is all incomplete right now until free agency/trades are done and then we can scrutinize what our starting rotation looks like.Currently we have.......Burke, May, Taylor, open, open.....I truly think we are going to get another quality starter and then let guys like Thorpe, Kay, others fight it out for the 5th spot. BUT....let's see what happens
7 hours ago7 hr 2 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:No, it cost Boston Smith and Davis Martin. Far from free.60% of Rockies' rotation is from the White Sox in the form of Martin, Mason Adams and Castillo.Ofc they might threaten White Sox record for futility with four consecutive 100+ loss seasons of their own. Edited 7 hours ago7 hr by caulfield12
6 hours ago6 hr 9 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:No, it cost Boston Smith and Davis Martin. Far from free.Yeah, I'd prefer to still have Boston Smith, Davis Martin and Dominguez (who you could probably either use yourself or trade pretty easily) but here we are.
6 hours ago6 hr 12 hours ago, chitownsportsfan said:The sign of an elite leader is one that is willing to admit a mistake immediately rather than continue walking the wrong way -- "the Godfather is a man that insists on hearing bad news as soon as possible".Some of the chattering baboons here are happier they were "proven right" about the Castillo deal than that their GM immediately righted a mistake. The castillo deal is done and dusted, it had zero to do with today's move and now, it only hurt them for three months, instead of another season.The Sox aren't "desperate" for 1 WAR 5th and 6th starters. Nobody is. Those guys are literally available every spring for a MiLB invite or are already on your AAA team. That we got rid of a 5th and 6th starter and saved 27 million is BRILIANT WORK.Yep. It shows that Getz understands that a number four starter on the team a year ago is no longer on the level of a team that is competition an AL pennant. It's cut throat and it's brutal but it has to be done.
6 hours ago6 hr 9 minutes ago, 2Deep said:Lots of interesting takes and reactions here about MAY and then the trade of CASTILLO and MARTIN.To me, this is all incomplete right now until free agency/trades are done and then we can scrutinize what our starting rotation looks like.Currently we have.......Burke, May, Taylor, open, open.....I truly think we are going to get another quality starter and then let guys like Thorpe, Kay, others fight it out for the 5th spot.BUT....let's see what happensThey absolutely have to get a real #1 or #2 now. We are talking Skubal, King, or Peralta. AND you still need a 150-200 starting innings that we might not have.
6 hours ago6 hr 1 minute ago, southsider2k5 said:They absolutely have to get a real #1 or #2 now. We are talking Skubal, King, or Peralta. AND you still need a 150-200 starting innings that we might not have.All of those innings won't be covered by 5 guys. Baseball is different now and we may have 8 different starters cover those innings. The days of having 5 starters is gone.......you need about 8 and then guys who can eat innings in the Pen.
6 hours ago6 hr 1 minute ago, Bob Sacamano said:Yeah, I'd prefer to still have Boston Smith, Davis Martin and Dominguez (who you could probably either use yourself or trade pretty easily) but here we are.If you look at it in its purest form, we traded Smith, Martin and Domiguez for a guy who throws slower than I drive on the Skyway, plus a 17 year old catcher no one knows anything about. Sure it looks better if you take a snapshot and edit the rest out of the picture, but it still means we have multiple starting pitching moves to make if we really want to act like a real playoff team. But we all can see Jerry still doesn't see this as a playoff team worth ACTUALLY investing in.
6 hours ago6 hr Just now, 2Deep said:All of those innings won't be covered by 5 guys. Baseball is different now and we may have 8 different starters cover those innings. The days of having 5 starters is gone.......you need about 8 and then guys who can eat innings in the Pen.And we just subtracted two of them. The math aint mathing.
6 hours ago6 hr 2 minutes ago, Colome's Hat said:Yep. It shows that Getz understands that a number four starter on the team a year ago is no longer on the level of a team that is competition an AL pennant. It's cut throat and it's brutal but it has to be done.Why didn’t he understand that he needed more starting pitching 4 months ago rather than just a 5+ ERA Castillo?
6 hours ago6 hr Why does everyone like King so much?2026 was the worst K-BB% of his career, lowest swinging strike rate, lowest strikeout rate, highest walk rate, highest xFIP, xERA and SIERA. His ERA seems to be a result of getting really lucky on BABIP and stranded-rate. Seems like a big regression candidate to me. I'd hate to spend ace money on him.I like Peralta better but that big drop in strikeouts also worries me. Even though the results were better with Tampa his strikeouts declined even further with them.Give me Rogers. He's been easily the best of the non-Skubal pitchers the last two years.
6 hours ago6 hr 1 minute ago, WhiteSox2023 said:Why didn’t he understand that he needed more starting pitching 4 months ago rather than just a 5+ ERA Castillo?And Martin/May had very comparable second halves...
6 hours ago6 hr 3 minutes ago, OmarComing25 said:Why does everyone like King so much?2026 was the worst K-BB% of his career, lowest swinging strike rate, lowest strikeout rate, highest walk rate, highest xFIP, xERA and SIERA. His ERA seems to be a result of getting really lucky on BABIP and stranded-rate. Seems like a big regression candidate to me. I'd hate to spend ace money on him.I like Peralta better but that big drop in strikeouts also worries me. Even though the results were better with Tampa his strikeouts declined even further with them.Give me Rogers. He's been easily the best of the non-Skubal pitchers the last two years.My co worker is cousins with Peralta. Maybe I can do some inside work
6 hours ago6 hr This seems like fake news.........the only reality is the Rockies do things to keep losing.Hoping the Sox move further away from that trend.
6 hours ago6 hr 1 minute ago, OmarComing25 said:Why does everyone like King so much?2026 was the worst K-BB% of his career, lowest swinging strike rate, lowest strikeout rate, highest walk rate, highest xFIP, xERA and SIERA. His ERA seems to be a result of getting really lucky on BABIP and stranded-rate. Seems like a big regression candidate to me. I'd hate to spend ace money on him.I like Peralta better but that big drop in strikeouts also worries me. Even though the results were better with Tampa his strikeouts declined even further with them.Give me Rogers. He's been easily the best of the non-Skubal pitchers the last two years.It's more for 2025 IMO.Injuries were somewhat limiting this year.Plus with King is not as much mileage with all the reliever seasons.But that's also an injury risk/predictor breaking down with extended work loads and often into postseasons.SD has a bigger outfield and the ball doesn't carry well 65% of the time.Also the advantage of Merrill and Tatis as Gold Glove caliber outfielders backing him up as a flyball/K dependent pitcher.It's simply because there aren't many great pitching options this year because so many young players are increasingly locked up earlier and earlier.It's really only Peralta Rogers and King in that second FA tier, with Taira and Holmes following.Scarcity. Edited 6 hours ago6 hr by caulfield12
6 hours ago6 hr 8 minutes ago, OmarComing25 said:Why does everyone like King so much?2026 was the worst K-BB% of his career, lowest swinging strike rate, lowest strikeout rate, highest walk rate, highest xFIP, xERA and SIERA. His ERA seems to be a result of getting really lucky on BABIP and stranded-rate. Seems like a big regression candidate to me. I'd hate to spend ace money on him.I like Peralta better but that big drop in strikeouts also worries me. Even though the results were better with Tampa his strikeouts declined even further with them.Give me Rogers. He's been easily the best of the non-Skubal pitchers the last two years.Definitely could use a lefty.
6 hours ago6 hr 5 minutes ago, Colome's Hat said:My co worker is cousins with Peralta. Maybe I can do some inside work5 minutes ago, Colome's Hat said:My co worker is cousins with Peralta. Maybe I can do some inside workKnow Jay and Alonso too?South Florida DR connection... Edited 6 hours ago6 hr by caulfield12
6 hours ago6 hr 12 minutes ago, southsider2k5 said:And we just subtracted two of them. The math aint mathing.Like I said.....I will wait until free agency/trades are done to make any judgements
6 hours ago6 hr 41 minutes ago, Look at Ray Ray Run said:#NameTeamWLSVGGSIPK/9BB/9HR/9BABIPLOB%GB%HR/FBvFA (pi)ERAxERAFIPxFIPWAR1Dustin May2 Tms230141456.29.374.131.11.31272.5%37.7%11.3%96.74.925.454.324.360.62Davis MartinCHW040111045.25.912.961.58.28467.5%44.3%13.6%93.35.125.405.445.120.0You are free to compare the two. I’m not over here pounding my chest about May. Not all that excited about him either
6 hours ago6 hr 7 minutes ago, kitekrazy1 said:This seems like fake news.........the only reality is the Rockies do things to keep losing.Hoping the Sox move further away from that trend.TBH? They are doing what I wish the Sox had done more of in 2024-26 where they acquired a guy like like by taking on a bad deal. But that is a story for another day.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.