2 hours ago2 hr Just now, WhiteSox2023 said:Best post of this thread. Getz made a mistake in giving up Boston Smith for Castillo and his bad salary. Now he has to include 4 cheap years of a decent starter in Davis just to dump Castillo to free up money just to replace Davis.How is anyone giving Getz credit for this? Dude is chasing his tail in circles like a dumb dog.lol davis martin will be pitching in japan in 2029. you don't lose moving on from a 1 WAR player, no matter how cheap they are. this is the anti white sox move in every fucking way my entire lifetime post 90s. this is fucking amazing.
2 hours ago2 hr 4 minutes ago, fathom said:The one thing I will never understand is how Getz thought he’d want Castillo at 25 million in 2027.I think he viewed it as 13 million or whatever. By dumping Dominguez. It was a mistake regardless.
2 hours ago2 hr 4 minutes ago, fathom said:The one thing I will never understand is how Getz thought he’d want Castillo at 25 million in 2027.My hope would be this is a learning experience for a young GM, they clearly saw something they believed they could fix, and obviously it didn’t work, at all.
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, fathom said:Just pure speculation on my end, but I think Rogers would be JR’s choice over Peralta/King. Lefties seem to be his favorite for the bigger money.Danks? lol
2 hours ago2 hr 1 minute ago, WhiteSox2023 said:Best post of this thread. Getz made a mistake in giving up Boston Smith for Castillo and his bad salary. Now he has to include 4 cheap years of a decent starter in Davis just to dump Castillo to free up money just to replace Davis.How is anyone giving Getz credit for this? Dude is chasing his tail in circles like a dumb dog.Decent is doing a whole lotta work in this post.
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, mmmmmbeeer said:Decent is doing a whole lotta work in this post.And if this move wasn't made, he would be saying how he can't believe we didn't find a starter better than Davis Martin going into the season.
2 hours ago2 hr I'm just going to be this guy all offseason...I don't hate it, I don't love it, I'm going to let all this play out until I make final judgements. I will say, that I do like the fact that Getz wasn't stubborn about fucking up and got rid of Castillo with his salary basically as fast as he could. That said, he was the one that got us in that situation and I do think Davis if healthy is a fine 4 or 5th starter. Like I said, some positive, some negative, let's see how this plays out. Edited 2 hours ago2 hr by Rowand44
2 hours ago2 hr 8 minutes ago, Baron said:Was Davis Martin going to be starting past May next year?I sure don't think so.
2 hours ago2 hr 1 minute ago, chitownsportsfan said:lol davis martin will be pitching in japan in 2029. you don't lose moving on from a 1 WAR player, no matter how cheap they are. this is the anti white sox move in every fucking way my entire lifetime post 90s. this is fucking amazing.Dustin May — 2.8 fWARDavis Martin — 2.6 fWAROne guys earning $17.5 million, the other is earning near minimum. Like I said, Getz is chasing his own tail with these moves. Edited 2 hours ago2 hr by WhiteSox2023
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, WhiteSox2023 said:Huh?Dustin May — 2.8 fWARDavis Martin — 2.6 fWAROne guys earning $17.5 million, the other is earning near minimum. Like I said, Getz is chasing his own tail with these moves.Davis had a first half he will never repeat again in his life.
2 hours ago2 hr 1 minute ago, Rowand44 said:I'm just going to be this guy all offseason...I don't hate it, I don't love it, I'm going to let all this play out until I make final judgements. I will say, that I do like the fact that Getz wasn't stubborn about fucking up and got rid of Castillo with his salary basically as fast as he can. That said, he was the one that got us in that situation and I do think Davis if healthy is a fine 4 or 5th starter. Like I said, some positive, some negative, lets see how this plays out.How dare you be smart.
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, WhiteSox2023 said:Huh?Dustin May — 2.8 fWARDavis Martin — 2.6 fWAROne guys earning $17.5 million, the other is earning near minimum. Like I said, Getz is chasing his own tail with these moves.Oh boy lol
2 hours ago2 hr Would you rather have Davis Martin or 25 million in payroll flexibility that we didnt have an hour ago?I know my answer.
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, Bonemer, I Hardly Know Her said:Would you rather have Davis Martin or 25 million in payroll flexibility that we didnt have an hour ago?I know my answer.Well said
2 hours ago2 hr We had to give up 4 years of control of a league average starter to dump Castillo. That's terrible. I know they probably don't think much of Martin given how he barely pitched in the playoffs, but that's bad business.
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, WhiteSox2023 said:Huh?Dustin May — 2.8 fWARDavis Martin — 2.6 fWAROne guys earning $17.5 million, the other is earning near minimum. Like I said, Getz is chasing his own tail with these moves.steamer thinks May is a half run better in era next year and .4 fWAR better in roughly the same innings. The White Sox staff clearly thinks Davis stinks and have moved on from a mistake using a dumb FO in Denver as the mark. I love this.
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, Rowand44 said:I'm just going to be this guy all offseason...I don't hate it, I don't love it, I'm going to let all this play out until I make final judgements. I will say, that I do like the fact that Getz wasn't stubborn about fucking up and got rid of Castillo with his salary basically as fast as he can. That said, he was the one that got us in that situation and I do think Davis if healthy is a fine 4 or 5th starter. Like I said, some positive, some negative, lets see how this plays out.A lot of us have been posting and following this sport for many years, but it’s like people never learn that you can’t judge moves as stand alone transactions. If the Sox made a big move, THEN made this trade, people would be thrilled. But it doesn’t always work that way. If there isn’t a quality starting pitcher added before the start of the season (whenever the f*** that is) then I’ll be lining up to grab my pitchfork. But would be dumb to do that now.
2 hours ago2 hr I can't stress this enough: Getz is clearly operating like the floor is going to happen. It's gonna happen imo, the POS owners want it, and they will get it in exchange for whatever the MLBPA can extract otherwise. The floor is the least of the MLBPA's worries and the owners will use it as a bargaining point for shitty old vets to get paid more. It is what it is.
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, chitownsportsfan said:I can't stress this enough: Getz is clearly operating like the floor is going to happen. It's gonna happen imo, the POS owners want it, and they will get it in exchange for whatever the MLBPA can extract otherwise. The floor is the least of the MLBPA's worries and the owners will use it as a bargaining point for shitty old vets to get paid more. It is what it is.If he was operating like there will be a floor, would he need to unload Castillo’s deal? Not arguing, just wondering the thought process you have.
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, chw42 said:We had to give up 4 years of control of a league average starter to dump Castillo. That's terrible. I know they probably don't think much of Martin given how he barely pitched in the playoffs, but that's bad business.Bingo. I can’t imagine giving credit to Getz for this trade considering it resulted from him having one of the worst trade deadlines in history less than 4 months ago. What a joke.
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, fathom said:If he was operating like there will be a floor, would he need to unload Castillo’s deal? Not arguing, just wondering the thought process you have.clearing out dead wood so you can plant something better is my process, and in this case planting nothing won't be an option.
2 hours ago2 hr 4 minutes ago, chitownsportsfan said:steamer thinks May is a half run better in era next year and .4 fWAR better in roughly the same innings. The White Sox staff clearly thinks Davis stinks and have moved on from a mistake using a dumb FO in Denver as the mark. I love this.Predictions are just that. It’s possible that he will still be a league average starter going forward and he will be earning peanuts for the next 4 year and Martin and May are both 29. Getz just paid $52 million for one of those. Edited 2 hours ago2 hr by WhiteSox2023
2 hours ago2 hr Just now, fathom said:Can we trade Benintendi with someone like Quero and unload most of his deal next?I was just thinking about that. I like Beni but can we end this early.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.