42 minutes ago42 min 8 minutes ago, Look at Ray Ray Run said:IM not a fan of Martins but as was pointed out earlier, if may is worth 52 million, martin is worth at least half that. Pitching with semblance of success has value. Easy for fans to only remember the guy down the stretch.The Rockies thought Martin clearly had enough surplus value to overcome Castillo's $25 million salary next year.
41 minutes ago41 min 1 minute ago, WhiteSox2023 said:At this point, there is no excuse to not sign a top tier FA starter. Getz signing two lesser FA starters would be more clown shoes.
40 minutes ago40 min Just now, chw42 said:The Rockies thought Martin clearly had enough surplus value to overcome Castillo's $25 million salary next year.Rockies aren’t exactly a beacon of great decisions, though.
39 minutes ago39 min Just now, PaleAleSox said:Rockies aren’t exactly a beacon of great decisions, though.Castillo is next year’s Michael Lorenzen for them
39 minutes ago39 min 1 minute ago, EloyJenkins said:This thread has exposed so many of you as just White Sox haters....not die hards of this team. Take your misery and shove it.Castillo... disaster. But he had pedigree, and Getz is willing to accept that consequence and move on (this is shocking under JR).Martin...go to the game threads from July on and not a single one of you said one nice thing. And he is 30! I honestly contemplated if he would make the rotation in 2027 based on his complete collapse. He wasnt going to get much on the trade market himself and was never replicating his first half ever again.May - i will bet my fandom that he will outperform what Martin will or would have produced the next 2-3 seasons. An overpay yes...but in the scheme of things that deal makes way more sense. He is their #4 starter next year#1 will be Taira/King/Peralta (i know some of you doubt this, but it just has to be to make this deal)#2 Burke#3 Taylor (only regret is Davis can provide his inning limit) this will be a playoff potential issue#4 May an overpay, but an upgrade of what Davis would have been (not many of you will agree, but it's clearly what Getz will own)#5 Kay on a short leash with all of the Charlotte guys trying to prove themselves (this is the result of Schultz being underwhelming, he really needs to figure it out)Plenty of mediocre depth.Is this riskier than trusting Davis to be better than 2nd half of Davis or that Castillo was going to figure it out? I definitely dont think so.The biggest question mark here is Kay. It's risky and i dont like it, but i trust him over Castillo at this point.I get the skepticism over them paying up for the #1 options, but if that happens, this is pretty hopeful with such a young core basically locked. I do think this could mean Braden sticks in RF...not sold on that one.Kay still being the #5 after already having a low payroll and all of these salary dumps would still be pretty sad.
37 minutes ago37 min 2 minutes ago, PaleAleSox said:Rockies aren’t exactly a beacon of great decisions, though.Getz has now provided Colorado 3/5 of their opening day starting rotation in the past 5 months.
37 minutes ago37 min Just now, chw42 said:Getz has now provided Colorado 3/5 of their opening day starting rotation in the past 5 months.Maybe we can get Mason Adams back for Doyle? I’d rather have him as the #5 than “Every Kiss Begins With Kay”. Edited 31 minutes ago31 min by WhiteSox2023
37 minutes ago37 min 17 minutes ago, fathom said:I think they like Schultz a lot.Doesn’t seem to me like they trust him to start off in the rotation. Maybe I’m wrong and them moving Martin is also evidence of that.I won’t be surprised if we sign Holmes and Taria.
33 minutes ago33 min 4 minutes ago, chw42 said:Getz has now provided Colorado 3/5 of their opening day starting rotation in the past 5 months.
33 minutes ago33 min 15 minutes ago, Ozzie for Manager said:I'm thinking Jerry is going after 2 SPs still. Or a SP and a good established closer.Forgot to add this is sarcasmIt shouldn’t be.
31 minutes ago31 min 6 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:They should have been able to afford it regardless of Castillo’s salary. I blame Getz for the bad Castillo trade but not this nickel and dime s%*# show. Jerry can’t sell soon enough.I dont get you. Never will I guess . You and others have been crying about Beni's salary for years and saying just eat it. They got rid of Castillo's Contract and didnt pay a nickel of it in 2027 and all it cost was Davis Martin to do it and he had a tenuous hold on his starting spot anyway. Just eating it is better ? If you had a declining asset and had a chance to clear it off the books wouldnt you do it ? Your boss will love you, the fans will love you and, if you or others were concerned about better FA signings it also gave more hope it that regard. It's a big leap if you are insinuating JR demanded Castillo's salary purged before anyone else was signed. I just think it was the best move for the organization . Just not sure why you seem upset. JR's got very little time left and the team has been ascending despite the cries about no pitching and no OF and we're on our way to another 100 loss season in the last offseason.
31 minutes ago31 min 5 minutes ago, chw42 said:Getz has now provided Colorado 3/5 of their opening day starting rotation in the past 5 months.Not that he was provided by Getz, but is Q still there?
30 minutes ago30 min Oddly the White Sox have probably been the most active team so far this offseason
29 minutes ago29 min Just now, Baron said:Oddly the White Sox have probably been the most active team so far this offseasonWhat a time to be alive
28 minutes ago28 min 1 minute ago, Baron said:Oddly the White Sox have probably been the most active team so far this offseasonSeems like every 3rd year, this happens
28 minutes ago28 min Thank god we won’t have the thought of Castillo pitching next season hanging over us during the lockout
28 minutes ago28 min 3 minutes ago, CaliSoxFanViaSWside said:I dont get you. Never will I guess . You and others have been crying about Beni's salary for years and saying just eat it. They got rid of Castillo's Contract and didnt pay a nickel of it in 2027 and all it cost was Davis Martin to do it and he had a tenuous hold on his starting spot anyway. Just eating it is better ?If you had a declining asset and had a chance to clear it off the books wouldnt you do it ? Your boss will love you, the fans will love you and, if you or others were concerned about better FA signings it also gave more hope it that regard.It's a big leap if you are insinuating JR demanded Castillo's salary purged before anyone else was signed. I just think it was the best move for the organization . Just not sure why you seem upset. JR's got very little time left and the team has been ascending despite the cries about no pitching and no OF and we're on our way to another 100 loss season in the last offseason.Don’t you think Martin would have been a good trade asset in a deal where Castillo wasn’t included?
28 minutes ago28 min 12 minutes ago, Soxfest said:Hopefully another SP signing soonOnly question should be is it before or after thanksgiving. It’s coming and I say before.
27 minutes ago27 min Author 2 minutes ago, BigHurt3515 said:Sullivan actually has some decent stats in his minor league career.Unfortunately he makes Thorpe look like a flamethrower. He had the lowest velocity of any MLB starter in 2026. Sits 87-88.
27 minutes ago27 min 1 hour ago, fathom said:If this is a salary dump, it pisses me off even more about the deadline. Sox are gonna have to sign more pitching.You didnt think the Sox were going to trade any pitching ? You should trust me more. I made several posts about the starting pitching depth might be used in trades. Even better getting rid of that contract which pretty much everyone agreed couldn't be done. They will sign more pitching . It's like Nov 19th . and hardly been any action from most teams and the Sox are dropping bombs. They are not done.
27 minutes ago27 min Just now, fathom said:Seems like every 3rd year, this happensI thought by this point this week we'd have more activity going on. Curious to see how the Thanksgiving week is approached by teams with the tuesday after the 1st day for the lockout.
26 minutes ago26 min 37 minutes ago, Look at Ray Ray Run said:Selling a salary dump as a payroll flexibility move. You guys should work for the organization.How is a team who didn't have any pitchers at the end of the year in better shape having given two pitchers away for free? Oh... because of the classic "the money will be spent" logic. As if they couldn't have spent the money anywaySmhYou’re living in a normal reality. I’m living in a JR reality. It’s okay to judge a move based on the actual restrictions that exist. Does it suck? Yes. But that’s the reality. So yes, I am feeling better about the team right now than I was a couple of hours ago. And you have zero confidence in Martin and Castillo. If we just “spent the money anyway” like you said, they likely wouldn’t be in the rotation for long anyway.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.