"I I'm not a big Andrew Vaughn fan, but you're making me one. Vaughn is 5'11, not 5'5. He's also been graded as a solid defender... 'm not trying to hound you from thread to thread, but your analysis boils down to "I don't like Vaughn. I like Abrams. Let me provide no truly substantive reasoning as to why."
I have a basis for my opinions and a right to express them on this fan forum. FYI, I have done what most fans interested in this Draft have done, namely I have searched for and read everything I can find on the players I think will be available at no. 3, including Vaughn and CJ Abrams. I have also watched numerous video highlights from their careers which I understand are just that - highlights., and looked over their available stats. This is something that was not as easy to do with a prep player like Abrams, but there is still a lot to be found on line about him. I have also looked at fan forum sites for the Orioles, Marlins and Tigers on their Draft topics just to see what their fans' opinions are on these players.
There are substantive reasons why the WS might not choose Vaughn over another a top player at another position. As others have pointed out, the Sox already have major league talent and numerous prospects that fit into the 1B/DH role. The fact is that 1B/DH is essentially a one tool position which is easier to fill than positions requiring more speed, athleticism, flexibility and a healthy, trim physique. I considered the potential upside of these players. Vaughn developed power after lifting weights (according to his own account) and gaining bulk. I am not sure how much more he can add to his frame and wonder, at what point added bulk (from age or weight lifting) begins to slow his swing and speed on the bases.
I looked for some example of a 6 ft. tall first basemen selected that high in the Draft that ended up being a star in the majors, and could not come up many examples. ...at least not in recent years. I even looked at Paul Konerko's rookie card . Even as a catcher, he was taller and far less bulky, or leg heavy (as Lillian pointed out) than Vaughn. Of course there have been guys who had a big azz and could hit like the Bull, Greg Luzinski, but they are always a liability on the bases and now, with the increased use of defensive shifts, their averages would have dropped.,
I am not going to defend Derek Jeter, but I do respect his opinion about a young shortstop's talent. My own opinion about CJ Abram is based on his athleticism, speed and that LH swing, and more than anything, scout evaluations. IMO, which is not an isolated one, CJ has tremendous upside potential. I just don't see that with Vaughn. He might end up being a guy who already maximized his talent , perhaps like another guy from Vandy we Drafted a few years ago.
And just to add, I expect that the White Sox will take Vaughn. I did not like most of the Draft selections they have made in recent years and I don't expect this year to be any different. Collins, Fulmer, Burgur...