This ranking only includes players who are still on the Sox. So no Hamilton, Lamb, Eaton, Hernandez, or Goodwin. I also didn't include Mercedes or Burger or Romy.
Against lefties. Plate appearances in parentheses.
Robert (68) 231
Grandal (96) 184
Abreu (153) 161
Vaughn (141) 156
Anderson (143) 125
Harrison (141) 114
Moncada (135) 99
Garcia (139) 91
Engel (49) 76
Zavala (30) 74
Eloy (59) 60
Collins (57) 57
Sheets (19) - 26
Against righties.
Engel (91) 154
Grandal (279) 150
Sheets (160) 143
Robert (228) 135
Moncada (462) 129
Anderson (408) 118
Abreu (506) 116
Eloy (172) 116
Garcia (335) 101
Collins (172) 101
Harrison (359) 99
Vaughn (328) 68
Zavala (74) 63
Aside from the small samples for several of these players, what would I draw from this?
1. Sheets/Vaughn are a tremendous platoon pairing, whether it's DH, 1B, or RF (or LF).
2. Sheets should get full-time duty against right handed pitching, as the 3rd best hitter against them on the team.
3. Andrew Vaughn will need to be eased in against right handed pitching. At the moment, he's only hitting them better than Seby Zavala. Yet he crushes lefties at the 4th best rate on the team, so sending him to AAA doesn't make much sense.
4. Adam Engel might be a better hitter than we give him credit for. He had reverse splits last year, but has hit lefties better in the past. If he can stay healthy and put up the kind of offensive numbers he has put up the last two years (121 and 127 wRC+), he should get a lot of time in RF.
5. Harrison and Garcia are pretty well matched as a platoon as well. But it's close enough that Harrison could be the primary 2B.
6. Garcia shouldn't get as many ABs as he had last year. But he probably will come close, given TLRs preferences.
7. Eloy isn't going to hit this bad or rank this low. If he does, our offense will be in trouble.
8. The Sox need 2019 Moncada back. His wRC+ numbers were 121 against lefties and 147 against righties.
9. The numbers for Luis Robert are artifically low because they include the first half. In the second half, his overall blended wRC+ was 173 compared to 125 in the first half.
10. Jose Abreu is still crushing lefties.