41 minutes ago41 min 16 minutes ago, PaleAleSox said:Rockies aren’t exactly a beacon of great decisions, though.Are they still paying Kris Bryant?
41 minutes ago41 min 1 minute ago, SoxBlanco said:You’re living in a normal reality. I’m living in a JR reality. It’s okay to judge a move based on the actual restrictions that exist. Does it suck? Yes. But that’s the reality.So yes, I am feeling better about the team right now than I was a couple of hours ago.And you have zero confidence in Martin and Castillo. If we just “spent the money anyway” like you said, they likely wouldn’t be in the rotation for long anyway.Well said.
41 minutes ago41 min 3 minutes ago, fathom said:Don’t you think Martin would have been a good trade asset in a deal where Castillo wasn’t included?Sure, but if the money needed to be moved to get a much better pitcher than both of them then it is what it is.
40 minutes ago40 min Just now, oldsox said:Sox will have lots of Openers in '27.Why do you think that?
39 minutes ago39 min 2 minutes ago, CaliSoxFanViaSWside said:I dont get you. Never will I guess . You and others have been crying about Beni's salary for years and saying just eat it. They got rid of Castillo's Contract and didnt pay a nickel of it in 2027 and all it cost was Davis Martin to do it and he had a tenuous hold on his starting spot anyway. Just eating it is better ?If you had a declining asset and had a chance to clear it off the books wouldnt you do it ? Your boss will love you, the fans will love you and, if you or others were concerned about better FA signings it also gave more hope it that regard.It's a big leap if you are insinuating JR demanded Castillo's salary purged before anyone else was signed. I just think it was the best move for the organization . Just not sure why you seem upset. JR's got very little time left and the team has been ascending despite the cries about no pitching and no OF and we're on our way to another 100 loss season in the last offseason.Getz isn’t setting the payroll on his own. He is given a number by Jerry. So to have money to sign the free agents he wants, he had to make this salary dump. I doubt he truly wanted to include Martin (a potential league average starter earning peanuts for 4 more years) just to dump Castillo’s salary but he realized how bad he fucked up that deadline trade. I saw numerous posters saying that the Sox should be able to spend a lot of money this offseason, regardless of Castillo’s salary. Obviously this trade proves that that belief was misguided.
39 minutes ago39 min 2 minutes ago, fathom said:Don’t you think Martin would have been a good trade asset in a deal where Castillo wasn’t included?If you saw a chance to get rid of that contract and all it took was DMart you don't do it ? Remember this off season sits still Starting Dec 1 for how many months where teams cant do anything? You make that deal every time in this kind of offseason. ARe you going to dick around trying to trade dMart when Colorado said we'll take him and eat the salary of Castillo. This was probably his only chance to shed that whole salary and maybe open up the just spend money to make the team better rather than trading youngsters. You wanted Taylor traded a 15 months ago and he can end up to be a great starting pitcher. Edited 34 minutes ago34 min by CaliSoxFanViaSWside
39 minutes ago39 min 1 minute ago, fathom said:Don’t you think Martin would have been a good trade asset in a deal where Castillo wasn’t included?The Castillo trade was really about opportunity cost. You cost yourself the opportunity to get a better starter to actually help the team last year. You cost yourself $25 million to sign a better starter in the off-season. And now, to actually sign a better starter, you gave up the opportunity to trade Davis Martin to help with another area of the team. People can say Martin sucks all they want because of how last season ended, but he projects to be a 1.5-2 WAR starter with 4 years of control. That has trade value in this league.
37 minutes ago37 min Just now, Baron said:Normally, I would say that it would be interesting to watch Martin versus May in performance the next 3 years but anyone pitching home games at Coors is fucked.
37 minutes ago37 min 1 minute ago, chw42 said:The Castillo trade was really about opportunity cost. You cost yourself the opportunity to get a better starter to actually help the team last year. You cost yourself $25 million to sign a better starter in the off-season. And now, to actually sign a better starter, you gave up the opportunity to trade Davis Martin to help with another area of the team. People can say Martin sucks all they want because of how last season ended, but he projects to be a 1.5-2 WAR starter with 4 years of control. That has trade value in this league.His aversion to rentals at the deadline still makes me want to punch daisies.
37 minutes ago37 min Author Just now, Lukakke Appling said:Anyone know how much this Veliz kid signed for?Via BA.Douglas Veliz, CAge: 17Veliz is a very young Venezuelan catcher who signed with the Rockies in 2026. At 5-foot-10, 186 pounds, he’s a stocky righthanded hitter with good contact skills, and the frame to eventually develop some power. He threw out 33% of attempted basestealers in 2026 in limited work (14 games) behind the plate.Like any 17-year-old catcher, Veliz has a long way to go developmentally. Early in the season, he was setting up with the conventional crouch, but he did start to use a one-knee setup with an increased focus on framing as the season wore on.He plays with energy and enthusiasm, and he showed a solid approach at the plate. He hit .300/.521/.450 in 29 games in the Dominican Summer League. That absurd on-base percentage is a function of the wildness of many DSL pitchers, but Veliz does know the strike zone, posting well above-average chase rates and very low in-zone miss rates when he swings. He had a sub-85 mph average exit velocity in 2026, but that should improve as he gets older and stronger.
37 minutes ago37 min 6 minutes ago, fathom said:Don’t you think Martin would have been a good trade asset in a deal where Castillo wasn’t included?Martin is projected to have a 1.6 fWAR next year at age 30. He’s had exactly 1/2 of a season where he looked like a good major league pitcher and has been 5th starter/long reliever on a bad team quality otherwise. They weren’t getting anything exciting for him.
36 minutes ago36 min Just now, WhiteSox2023 said:Normally, I would say that it would be interesting to watch Martin versus May in performance the next 3 years but anyone pitching home games at Coors is fucked.Getz probably thought there's no way he can lose this deal because Castillo and Martin are both going to get destroyed at Coors. Martin gives up too much hard contact and fly balls to be an effective pitcher at Coors Field.
34 minutes ago34 min 1 hour ago, chitownsportsfan said:one projected for 1.6 fWAR and an era in the mid 4s. a SP that had a velocity dip in the 2nd half and that the entire coaching staff didn't trust in the 2nd half. this is a great move. he was done in chicago one way or another. I'm not even sure he's in the rotation in the 2nd half for the rockies, dude is gonna get lit up.This franchise just spent Boston Smith and Davis Martin to get the $25 million they already had back.
33 minutes ago33 min 1 hour ago, chitownsportsfan said:the floor is coming bro, don't worry about spending money.Because this move screams they have money?
33 minutes ago33 min Just now, southsider2k5 said:This franchise just spent Boston Smith and Davis Martin to get the $25 million they already had back.You can’t count horrifyingly bad trades that Getz just made less than 4 months ago when assessing this bad trade. Try again.Honestly, glad you finally spelled it out in a post. That’s ghoulish. Edited 32 minutes ago32 min by WhiteSox2023
32 minutes ago32 min 4 minutes ago, hi8is said:His aversion to rentals at the deadline still makes me want to punch daisies.They traded for guys who had extra control and have gotten rid of 2 of their 4 acquisitions. So much for that.
32 minutes ago32 min 5 minutes ago, WhiteSox2023 said:Getz isn’t setting the payroll on his own. He is given a number by Jerry. So to have money to sign the free agents he wants, he had to make this salary dump. I doubt he truly wanted to include Martin (a potential league average starter earning peanuts for 4 more years) just to dump Castillo’s salary but he realized how bad he fucked up that deadline trade. I saw numerous posters saying that the Sox should be able to spend a lot of money this offseason, regardless of Castillo’s salary. Obviously this trade proves that that belief was misguided.its so weird you find so many reasons to dislike who they get and dislike who they get rid of . You wont say May could be a league average pitcher but you can say it about Davis Martin. You called it a brutal signing and 5th or 6th starter did you not ?
31 minutes ago31 min 1 hour ago, Bonemer, I Hardly Know Her said:Would you rather have Davis Martin or 25 million in payroll flexibility that we didnt have an hour ago?I know my answer.You should have both. This is a major market team getting out spent by the fucking Twins
29 minutes ago29 min Just now, CaliSoxFanViaSWside said:its so weird you find so many reasons to dislike who they get and dislike who they get rid of . You wont say May could be a league average pitcher but you can say it about Davis Martin. You called it a brutal signing and 5th or 6th starter did you not ?Nope, I called May a #4/#5 starter right now. But while both May and Martin could be league average starters next year, one dude will be making $17.5 million and one will be making near the minimum. There’s a big difference there.
29 minutes ago29 min Okay, I love this trade. But not in a “Getz rules!” sort of way.There’s something to be said about admitting you fucked up and moving on. It really sucks that the initial Castillo trade happened, cuz it definitely set them back, but it just is what is. It happened.I’ll take this move all day over them continuing to try convincing themselves that the initial Castillo trade will still pay off.
29 minutes ago29 min 59 minutes ago, Bonemer, I Hardly Know Her said:Do the whiners about this trade understand the sunk cost fallacy?Do the whiners understand DFA?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.