This is the crux of my view as well. With a butcher already committed to in LF, bringing in a statue like Mazara is a problem that can't be bridged easily. Giving Mazara the starting RF role is a mistake, IMO. Adding in a 37 year old Encarnacion effectively "blocks" Mazara from being hidden at DH, and it constipates the 1B/DH depth chart.
By contrast, Puig's issues can be bridged by:
1. The "makeable incentives" part of a contract to help keep him in line, [i.e. cash to him and to his charitable foundation if he toes the line],
2. Insuring the contract [i.e. if he steps out of line/is released, Lloyd's of London covers some of the contract],
3. Signing redundancy in the 26 man [i.e. a Corner OF/DH type that can play some corner OF, instead of yet another 1B/DH type like Encarnacion],
4. Trusting that men can evolve and mature [i.e. the issues from when he was 22 won't pop up now that he's 29 & with 3 kids],
5. Trusting that Abreu and Grandal are in fact good leaders that have vouched for who he is NOW,
6. Trusting that Ricky can do what he does best, which is to keep a harmonious and engaged clubhouse, and
7. [EDIT] Trusting/verifying that he's been humbled by the past few years and the lack of suitors this offseason.
I'm not sure there are [EDIT] 7 ways to bridge Mazara's 59 wrc+ v. LHP, nor his ineptitude at defense, nor Encarnacion's inevitable date with Father Time.