As one of the few positive posters on Soxtalk, I've been pretty quiet since the season began.
The team is just very disappointing on many levels. That doesn't mean it can't rally, but so far, so much of it has been unwatchable.
On offense, only Tim Anderson and Andrew Vaughn are above .800 OPS on the season. And only 4 players are above 100 wRC+. Robert and Abreu are the other two. (Not counting Danny Mendick and his 26 PAs). So many others have flat out stunk. Where is Yasmani Grandal, and why is he getting so many ABs at DH? Where is AJ Pollock? Yoan Moncada? You make us yearn for Jake Burger, and your contract is about to be a major albatross around the Sox' neck.
For pitching, Michael Kopech has been stellar. Lucas Giolito has also pitched well when he's been available. Johnny Cueto has been amazing in two starts. And even Dylan Cease has done pretty well, though he's also been blown up in 2 of his last 3 starts, which dropped his ERA+ down to 92. In the bullpen, there have been good performances, but also let downs. Matt Foster is one of the bright spots there.
On defense, it seems to have stabilized, but there were some early games lost with poor defense, including errors by Tim Anderson, the otherwise star of the team.
I won't break down Tony LaRussa other than to say he's made many inexcusable mistakes for a HOF manager. We often overrate "moves" by a manager, and underrate how a manager gets a team to play hard, but even on the latter score, TLR has not done well. There seems to be no team discipline.
Rick Hahn and the Sox front office? My biggest problem was not keeping Carlos Rodon, though after starting out with a great first month, he's been roughed up lately and is only 4-4 with a 113 ERA+. But other moves have not worked. Joe Kelly? He can't stay healthy. Not sure Ryan Tepera was the answer, as he's at a 95 ERA+ right now. But they spent a lot of money on Kelly and he hasn't given the Sox anything. AJ Pollock? Seemed like a great trade at the time. Good for a 70 OPS+ when he can play, which has had major gaps. Josh Harrison? Why? Frankly Danny Mendick would have been a better bridge to minor league guys. His money could have gone to keeping Rodon. At least the Nick Madrigal trade hasn't bit us, with Madrigal hurt and sporting a 40 OPS+. Will you finally cut Dallas Keuchel? By keeping him you send the team the wrong message, while losing games you can't afford to lose. He was such a bad signing. Without his contract, the Sox definitely could have afforded Rodon.
So there you have it. The players, the manager, and the front office have all performed very poorly this year.
I will leave with one final note. 1983. In the first half the team was 40-37. In the second half they were 59-26. TLR was the manager. Not saying it will happen again. But last year, the Atlanta Braves were 44-45 at one point on their way to the World Series.